Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

The Red Sea: a cautionary tale

The Gulf nations could use the latest shipping crisis as a stimulus to bolster food security

People celebrate on the deck of the commercial vessel Galaxy Leader owned by Japanese company NYK after it was seized by Yemen's Houthis Reuters/Khaled Abdullah
People celebrate on the deck of the commercial vessel Galaxy Leader owned by Japanese company NYK after it was seized by Yemen's Houthis

After weeks of speculation, the US and Britain have responded to Houthi attacks on shipping in the Red Sea with warplane and missile strikes on targets in Yemen. 

Following a spike in attacks, several of the world’s largest shipping companies said in mid-December that they were avoiding the waterway between the Arabian Peninsula and East Africa.

This waterway is one of the world’s major maritime choke points – approximately 15 percent of globally traded products flow through there. 

At this stage it would be wrong to sound the alarm bells too loudly. Dated Brent, the global benchmark for oil, is up a little over two percent and commodity markets generally are in wait-and-see mode. 

For now, there are numerous alternatives available to traders to ship goods to the GCC states via the Cape of Good Hope or airfreight. But there are implications if the crisis persists in the longer term. 

This especially relates to the trade in food, and grains in particular.

The Middle East and North Africa region imports the great majority of its strategic grain commodities, such as wheat and barley, from the Black Sea region, the EU and North America. 

Far less comes from the southern hemisphere for the simple reason that most grains are produced in the north. Wheat grown for export, for example, has a ratio of 80:20 in favour of the northern hemisphere. 

The important months for wheat traders are March, May, July, September, and October. This is when shipment deals are struck, and vast quantities are shipped across the globe.

We are not yet in March and the Chicago Wheat Future Index is still lower than a year ago. But if the crisis persists, wheat future prices are likely to respond. 

The wheat problem

While the Red Sea crisis is unlikely to cause physical shortages, prices may be affected. For now, importers are able to cushion any food import price increases, but this is where caution should set in. 

Despite fears over an all-out food crisis in 2022 after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, wheat markets were able to provide remedies due to bumper crops in Russia in 2022 and 2023, as well as a UN-brokered trading agreement in the Black Sea region. However, most of the wheat grown in Russia and Ukraine is rainfed. Summer rains have been good over the past few years. But climate change-induced droughts could affect this within months. 

If rainfall in the major production centres in the northern hemisphere disappoints this year or over the coming years, grain supplies are likely to be hit hard. An ongoing crisis in the Red Sea could therefore exert its full negative impact later in the year.

Freight costs may also contribute to food inflation, which has already seen several years of steep increases, especially in lower income countries

Wheat is still the predominant source of affordable calories in the Arab region, and consumption is significantly higher than in the countries of the OECD, the so-called rich country club.

Per-capita consumption per year is about 130kg in the Arab world compared to 85kg in the OECD. The six GCC economies consume about 90kg per person per year. 

Arab countries have tried to diversify their grain import sources for years with mixed levels of success. The cheapness of Russian wheat and ongoing economic crises mean that reliance on wheat imports from Eastern Europe and the Black Sea has not diminished. 

For the GCC and Sudan, all exports ideally need to cross the Red Sea. Other Arab countries may be affected by another round of wheat price spikes partly as a result of the Red Sea crisis. 

The key difference in the Red Sea is the nature of the conflict. For exporters and shipping companies, guerilla warfare of sub-national military groups can be more difficult to manage than inter-state conflicts. 

Opportunities to escape the grip of geopolitics 

The latest crisis in the Red Sea, along with previous crises have revealed the fragility of food supply chains to the Arab world. But the latest conflict could concentrate minds. 

Ideally, more strategic crops should be grown domestically. Wheat is not an ideal crop to be grown in the Arab world due to the absence of readily available water. Instead, drought-resistant and less water-intensive millet crops present the region with an opportunity to de-couple from world food markets. 

Foxtail millet, for example, can be grown in the hot conditions of the Arab Peninsula and can provide much-needed carbohydrates for growing populations. Although millet is more bitter than wheat, food scientists can work to mitigate the bitterness. 

This is a safer option to prepare the region for future climate-related and political challenges. 

After all, the Red Sea crisis may just be one of the many crises to come in an age of climate change and uncertain geopolitical events.

Martin Keulertz is a lecturer in environmental management at the University of the West of England, Bristol

Latest articles

Properties overlooking the bay in Muscat. Property prices in the capital fell more than 5 percent

Oman’s real estate sector continues to slide

Apartment prices in Oman dropped more than 17 percent in the first quarter of 2024, while villa prices rose a meagre 0.8 percent, according to the latest government figures. Residential real estate prices were down across the board quarter on quarter, including those for land. The Musandam region recorded the largest overall decline at 15.7 […]

Shoppers choose vegetables in Istanbul; inflation means people are spending on essentials

Turkish retailers’ confidence wavers as inflation bites

Confidence is falling among Turkish retailers, according to a survey from the country’s statistics agency Turkstat. Shoppers have been scaling back on big-ticket purchases, spending instead on basic consumer goods as inflation piles pressure on household incomes. May’s business confidence report, released by Turkstat on June 24, showed sentiment in the retail sector at its […]

Water is handed out to pilgrims in Mecca. Hundreds of pilgrims without a Hajj permit died during extreme heat last week

Egypt shuts down 16 travel companies after Hajj tragedy

Egypt has withdrawn the operating licences of 16 travel companies for organising unlicensed Hajj trips to Saudi Arabia. A statement from the Egyptian government said the companies would be prosecuted and fined, with the funds used to compensate pilgrims’ families for their loss.  Hundreds of Egyptians were among 1,301 people who died of exposure to […]

A floating production unit in Israel's Karish gas field in the eastern Mediterranean. Carlyle is creating a new oil and gas company to manage the field

New Carlyle entity to manage East Med gas projects

Carlyle, the Nasdaq-listed private equity company, is creating a new oil and gas company to manage recently-acquired assets in the Mediterranean hydrocarbons market. The new as yet un-named entity will be led by former BP CEO Tony Hayward and will manage a portfolio of gas-weighted exploration and production assets in Italy, Egypt and Croatia, according […]