Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

A just energy transition cannot be rushed

The JP Morgan thesis will get a resounding welcome among oil producers

A research paper from JP Morgan suggests that the energy transition will take decades, despite the demands of activists from groups such as Just Stop Oil Alisdare Hickson/Flickr/Creative Commons
A research paper from JP Morgan suggests that the energy transition will take decades, despite the demands of activist groups such as Just Stop Oil

As if there were not already sufficient uncertainties in global oil markets – Middle East security tensions, an accelerating war in Ukraine, energy sanctions and uncertainties in major economies – JP Morgan, the blue-blood American investment bank, has thrown another spanner into the works.

In a thought-provoking research paper published recently, the bank’s global energy strategist Christyan Malek has said that a “reality check” is required on the whole convoluted and controversial subject of the energy transition and the apparently inevitable shift from hydrocarbons towards renewables and alternative fuel sources.

If Malek’s thesis is correct, many of the existing orthodoxies of the energy transition will have to be re-thought. These include the natural decline in hydrocarbon production and usage, the fast-track replacement by electrification and renewables, and the 2050 targets for net-zero carbon levels.



The broad scenario advanced by the environmentalist lobby is that hydrocarbon usage will naturally wither away as consumers and governments realise the harmful effects of greenhouse gas emissions.

They either choose low-carbon options via the market mechanism or are “persuaded” by official policies to adopt a progressively lower-carbon energy regime.

For oil prices, this would mean a gradual downturn as demand falls off, the rate of demand decline depending on your choice. Peak 2030 seems fashionable at the moment, though some of the more aggressive green “experts” see it as earlier.

The oil-producing world, naturally, sees it much later. According to the standard position, hydrocarbons are an “essential part of the global energy mix for many years to come”.

Malek asks us to think again about time scales. “Throughout the course of history, each new energy source has taken multiple decades to achieve global scale,” he writes.

It took oil, gas and coal 41, 44 and 54 years respectively to go from 1 to 10 per cent of the global primary energy mix.

He estimates wind and solar currently at around 2-3 per cent of global energy; other forms, like hydro and nuclear, which have been around much longer, have never reached the 10 per cent threshold.

Second, he questions funding models. Scaling up wind and solar will be much more expensive than comparable epoch-changing projects, like the Manhattan Project to develop the atomic bomb or the US Apollo Program to land people on the moon.

Instead of a mad scramble towards unrealistic targets (‘Just Stop Oil’), energy policymakers should go for the ‘low-hanging fruit’

Private sector investment returns on renewables have not been impressive, Malek writes, and amid the current tense geopolitical and economic uncertainties, governments are under pressure to spend public money on other things, such as defence, welfare and higher interest rates.

Finally, he points out – as Elon Musk of Tesla is beginning to realise – that developing clean energy systems itself requires vast amounts of energy expenditure, with an associated cost.

For example, four tech companies – Amazon, Apple, Alphabet and Meta – consumed more energy than the whole of Columbia or Czechia in 2022.

As some western governments have already learned, there is no inevitable sympathy on the part of their electorates towards radical environmental policies and there could be further pushback as financial and economic reality takes hold, as it did in Europe after the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

So instead of a mad scramble towards unrealistic targets (“Just Stop Oil”), energy policymakers should go for the “low-hanging fruit” that can actually be implemented and which would produce meaningful reductions in emissions. A global switch from coal to gas would cut greenhouse gases by 17 per cent, Malek estimates.

And, because emissions are worldwide phenomena, a move to a global carbon market is the best way to balance public and private investment, with a global carbon price setting a consistent benchmark.

“Transition cannot be rushed, it is by definition a decades- or generations-long process and long-term strategies are critical to ensure a ‘just’ transition,” Malek concludes.

The JP Morgan thesis will get a resounding welcome among the oil producers – where the bank already has considerable heft – but will almost certainly be demonised by the environmentalists.

It will also be another factor the traders have to feed into their increasingly complex long-term modelling, alongside Gaza, Kharkiv and Hormuz.

Frank Kane is Editor-at-Large of AGBI and an award-winning business journalist. He acts as a consultant to the Ministry of Energy of Saudi Arabia and is a media adviser to First Abu Dhabi Bank of the UAE

Latest articles

The new technology can help with tracking projects as contractors often have no idea how many workers are on site at one time and workers are frequently unsupervised

Saudi startup’s smart helmets upping safety on building sites

When Hassan AlBalawi first proposed a smart helmet that would track all employee movements on building sites, construction companies could not see the point.  “We were focusing on this problem of how to get technology into the construction field, measuring the drowsiness of construction workers. But it turned out the construction companies didn’t know or care,” […]

Aircraft, Airliner, Airplane

Kuwait Airways 2023 revenue soars 16% to $1bn

Increased passenger volume and flight operations increased revenues at Kuwait Airways by 16 percent in 2023. The topline reached KD335 million ($1.1 billion) last year, as the number of flights soared 26 percent year on year to 32,839, the state-run Kuwait News Agency reported, citing chairman Abdulmohsen Alfagaan. No details were shared on profit or […]

A Mitsubishi H3 rocket on the launchpad in Japan. The UAE will use the model in its asteroid belt mission

UAE and Mitsubishi sign agreement for asteroid belt mission

The UAE has signed an agreement with Mitsubishi Heavy Industries to provide services for its 2028 mission to the asteroid belt.  The Emirates Mission to the Asteroid Belt – the first multiple-asteroid tour and landing mission to the main belt that lies between Mars and Jupiter – will launch the Mohammed Bin Rashid Explorer spacecraft […]

Outdoors, Ground, Nature

IMF gives Jordan access to $131m as reforms continue

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) will grant Jordan access to $131 million as the country’s economic reform programme remains strong despite it facing a challenging external environment. The release of the funds remains subject to approval by the IMF’s management and executive board. “Jordan continues to show resilience and maintain macro-economic stability, despite the headwinds […]