Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

It’s official: Opec is a source of price stability in oil markets

A report published by the Fed highlights oil producers' role in preventing crude spikes

A woman at petrol pump. US politicians who label Opec a price-fixing cartel may have to rethink Pexels/Gustavo Fring
Petrol prices are likely to be a hot topic in November's US elections. The country's politicians who label Opec a price-fixing cartel may have to rethink

It is difficult to overstate the bogey-man status that American policymakers ascribe to the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries.

US presidents routinely label Opec a “price-fixing cartel” in global crude markets, while Congress members threaten dire consequences if the oil producers cut output, or do not cut output, or leave output where it is.

Chuck Grassley, a Republican senator from Iowa, sponsored a bill to bring anti-trust legislation against the countries last year, saying: “We’ve seen time and again how Opec has colluded to set global oil prices, bringing uncertainty and high prices to consumers around the globe.”

Well, the senator will have to think again because it has emerged from an authoritative US study that, actually, Opec “reduces oil price volatility and prompts market participants to rebalance their positions”.

That verdict, distinctly at odds with the view from the partisan Washington “swamp”, is the conclusion of a long and densely analytical research paper published by the US Federal Reserve, titled Reasons Behind Words: Opec Narratives and the Oil Market.

Over more than 50 pages, the authors – a policy wonk from the Federal Reserve Board and two French academics – break down the effect of Opec decisions, communications and “signalling” on global oil markets.

They find that, far from “bringing uncertainty and high prices”, Opec has been a force for price stability and moderation.

My favourite bit of gobbledygook

The paper is part of the Federal Reserve Board’s Finance and Economics Discussion Series and it is not an easy read, with much discussion of academic methodology and modelling. “Estimated coefficients of the penalized bootstrap Lasso regressions for trading positions” was my favourite bit of gobbledygook.  

Nor can you envy the authors their task. They analysed every Opec press release and public statement between 2002 and 2021, and plotted those against actual movements in the crude oil price (using West Texas Intermediate as their benchmark) and trading volumes on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, the big US oil trading market.

That period takes in three important periods of oil price volatility: the global financial crisis that began in 2008, the surge in US shale oil output between 2015 and 2017 and the start of the Covid pandemic in early 2020.

On all three occasions, they conclude, Opec communications were effective in calming global markets and ironing out price spikes that threatened disaster for global energy markets and economies.

Outside the authors’ remit – though perhaps more illustrative of Opec’s ability to deliver decisive action to reassure markets – were the wider measures taken in the wake of the oil price collapse in April 2020.

Then, as US oil producers were briefly paying consumers to take the barrels away, Opec and other market players got together to produce the biggest oil cut in history, a historic event that led to a gradual steadying of the ship.

This has continued to the present day. Given the stressful geopolitical situation, with open military confrontations in the Middle East, Europe and Africa that have the potential to escalate into much bigger conflicts, it is remarkable how comparatively stable the price of crude has been, anchored largely in the $75 to $80 per barrel range.

Opec communications calmed global markets and ironed out price spikes that threatened disaster

This stability is mainly due to the ongoing Opec policy of output restraint, led by Saudi Arabia, even as other producers such as the US, Iran and Venezuela significantly increase production.

It is important to point out that the report confined its parameters to Opec, rather than the broader Opec+, which includes Russia, itself a source of energy volatility since the invasion of Ukraine.

The report asks whether Opec pronouncements are “cheap talk or credible signal”. It concludes: “Opec narratives cover a wide range of topics that are indeed linked to the fundamental factors we consider.” For those in the US who think Opec is a political tool of the Middle East, the authors decide that “Opec narratives are based on crude market fundamentals”.

Both Joe Biden and Donald Trump – obsessed by the electoral impact of gas prices – have made great political capital out of Opec in the past, and will probably do so again if they line up against each other once more in November.

They should each get an aide to summarise the Fed report before they start the mud-slinging.

Frank Kane is Editor-at-Large of AGBI and an award-winning business journalist. He acts as a consultant to the Ministry of Energy of Saudi Arabia and is a media adviser to First Abu Dhabi Bank of the UAE

Latest articles

EGSH

Dubai launches one-stop hub to streamline government services

People in Dubai can now obtain an Emirates ID, register a company, open a bank account and more under one roof following the opening of the Emirates Government Services Hub (EGSH). Owned by Sheikh Mohammed Bin Maktoum Bin Juma Al Maktoum, a member of the Dubai Royal family, EGSH allows clients to access all essential […]

In association with
Thailand's consul general Kitinai Nutakul visits the Saudi Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Jeddah

Thailand opens investment office in Saudi Arabia

Thailand’s Board of Investment (BOI) is opening its first Middle East office in Saudi Arabia, signaling a deepening of economic ties between the nations after a longstanding diplomatic spat. The office will focus on attracting Saudi investment into Thailand’s targeted industries and supporting Thai entrepreneurs looking to invest in the region, the BOI said in […]

hajj saudi arabia

Saudia reports big rise in international passengers

Saudi Arabia’s national carrier Saudia reported a 24 percent increase in international passengers to 9.1 million in the first half of 2024. There was also a 13 percent rise in the number of flights. The Hajj pilgrimage in June played a large part in the growth.  The number of passengers flying on domestic routes rose […]

renewables target dam

World is off track to meet Cop28 renewables goal

The world is far from reaching its 2030 renewables target, the International Renewable Energy Agency (Irena) said on Thursday. Countries committed at the Cop28 summit in Dubai last year to treble renewables capacity in order to limit global warming to 1.5C. To stay on course global capacity growth needs to accelerate to a minimum rate […]