Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

Saudi and the Brics: a test case for multi-polarity

There is a case for a global economic alliance

Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping Reuters/Danish Siddiqui
Saudi Arabia is among many nations bidding to join the Brics grouping whose member states' leaders include Russia's Putin and China's Xi

I wonder if Baron O’Neill of Gatley wakes in the middle of the night in a cold sweat wondering what exactly he has done.

Back in 2001 O’Neill – then just plain “Jim” – invented a radical new category in global asset management, the Bric economies.

His thesis was that the potential for economic growth in Brazil, Russia, India and China qualified them to be regarded as a special investment opportunity.

South Africa was added to the grouping in 2010 to create the one we now know as the Brics, which is on the verge of a big expansion when the next summit of leaders takes place in August.

According to reports, 19 other countries have applied formally to join the Brics, including Saudi Arabia and Iran. Others have expressed interest in future involvement, among them Argentina, the UAE, Algeria, Egypt, Bahrain and Indonesia, as well as several African countries as yet unidentified.

Exactly how many actually join is uncertain, but one thing is sure: the old acronym will not do for the future. Some branding agency somewhere is set for a big payday when the Brics are renamed.

When it was the original four Bric nations, there was an economic rationale that O’Neill explained eloquently and successfully. With big and growing populations, fast projected rates of GDP growth and aspirational middle classes, the Bric countries were set to take off – and Western investors with a taste for exotic emerging markets could profit from that.

The formula worked until 2008, when the global financial crisis hit them hard, along with the rest of the world. That was also the year Russia invaded Georgia, which first gave rise to worries about investing in ‘rogue’ Russia. Those fears have come full circle today with sweeping sanctions against Russia over its invasion of Ukraine.

Bloomberg recently calculated that returns from Brics investments over the past five years have underperformed other emerging market peers. So the overall investment case is inconclusive.

Imbalances within the Brics grouping have also become more significant. China was always the biggest by far of the four-then-five, raising the suspicion that it was merely a construct for China to secure energy sources, commodities and foodstuffs from its partners in exchange for Chinese manufactured goods.

It is important to understand that the Brics is not a free trade grouping like the European Union, or even the more limited moves towards economic integration by the likes of the Association of South East Asian Nations or the Gulf Co-operation Council.

Rather, its limited achievements have been confined to the financial sphere. In 2016, the five set up a $100 billion pool of foreign reserves, to be tapped by members in times of emergency.

They also established the New Development Bank (NDB), sometimes called the Brics bank, which has made some big investments in infrastructure in the poorer parts of the grouping.

Tentative plans to consider a Brics common currency will be discussed at the August summit, but an agglomeration of reals, roubles, rupees, renminbi and rand is not, on the face of it, an overwhelmingly attractive proposition.

Perhaps it has a possible future role as an instrument for intra-Brics trade, but for now the US dollar faces no serious challenge from the Brics as the world’s reserve currency.

One imminent development could be the inclusion of Saudi Arabia in the Brics bank, being discussed at the NDB’s annual meeting this week. From the Saudi side, that would further cement its growing relationship with China (the NDB is based in Shanghai) and would also help plug the gap left by sanctioned Russia when it comes to raising international funds.

How far the Brics go beyond that remains to be seen. There is a case for a global economic alliance, with Saudi and Middle East involvement, to counter-balance the West.

Multi-polarity is a fact of life in the modern world and the West has had its own way for too long via the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the G7 and other US or European institutions.

But is Brics the way to do that? Beyond the fact of anti-Western sentiment that seems to bind the five together – greatly heightened by the war in Ukraine – there is little of substance that unites them. That would be even more the case if the planned big expansion actually happens.

If the Brics grouping turns into another divisive agency on the global economic and financial scene, it would prove a big distraction from the enormous challenges the world faces.

It could turn into O’Neill’s own version of Frankenstein’s monster.

Frank Kane is Editor-at-Large of AGBI

Latest articles

UAE France

Climate transition galvanises ties between UAE and France

Climate transition is becoming a central focus of economic cooperation between the UAE and France as the countries agreed to establish a “Bilateral Climate Investment Platform”. The platform aims to accelerate joint projects and investments in clean energy sectors, with a particular focus on advancing the decarbonisation of industries such as steel, cement and petrochemicals. […]

UAE new cairo

UAE developer to build $2bn project in Egypt’s New Cairo

Egypt’s New Urban Communities Authority and the UAE’s UDC Real Estate Development Company have signed a contract to develop an EGP60 billion ($1.9 billion) urban development project in New Cairo. Named The Crest, the development in the Hadayek Al-Andalus area will be built on a plot spanning 665,000 sq m. It will comprise residential, commercial […]

Baghdad South power plant: Iraq generates 80% of its power using fossil fuels

Iraq plans push on solar and green hydrogen projects

Iraq is planning to build solar plants and its first green hydrogen project as part of a strategy to tackle power shortages and reduce its carbon footprint. The country’s cabinet has approved a proposal to install 12 gigawatts (GW) of solar power by 2030, said a National Investment Commission representative, Rahim Al Jaafari. Projects capable […]

Neom wellness Elanan

Neom announces ‘ultra-modern’ wellness resort

Saudi Arabia’s mega-city Neom has announced plans for another wellness resort on the Gulf of Aqaba.  The new site, Elanan, will be a wellness resort with architecture that uses “ultra-modern design techniques to form intricate sculptures that merge with the surrounding natural beauty,” Neom said on its website. The website shows images of a futuristic-looking […]