Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

G7 should opt for fuel tax cut over price cap, says Saudi-based analyst

Creative Commons
G7 countries are keen to lower fuel costs but debate rages over the best way forward
  • Feasibility of implementing price caps is doubtful
  • Each G7 country has its own energy market structures 
  • Regulations stop G7 EU countries subsidising energy domestically

A proposal by the G7 group of leaders to look at the feasibility of introducing a price cap on energy imports was dismissed as “highly doubtful” by a top Saudi-based energy analyst.

A report by the Financial Times on Tuesday claimed that the G7 leaders – which includes Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the UK and US – were exploring an option to introduce a temporary price cap on energy imports, as part of a package of economic measures against Russia, and to halt the soaring cost of fuel on Western consumers.

“The feasibility of implementing such price caps is highly doubtful,” Ramy Al-Ashmawy, senior energy specialist at the Saudi-based Arab Petroleum Investments Corporation (APICORP), told AGBI.

“The first issue to consider is that G7 countries are not a homogeneous group.

“Each country has its own energy market structures and dynamics. Moreover, EU regulations will not allow certain countries in the G7 bloc to essentially ‘subsidise’ energy domestically, at the expense of other non-G7 EU countries.

“The second issue to consider is the scope of this cap: will it be placed on commercial energy prices or non-commercial (eg residential), or both? And on which energy products will it be placed (gasoline, electricity, LPG/natural gas, etc.)?” 

During the first three months of this year the price of Brent crude rose 29 percent quarter-on-quarter to reach an average of $103 a barrel, its highest level since the third quarter of 2014. In 2020, as demand collapsed on the back of the coronavirus pandemic, Brent crude averaged just $42 a barrel.

Fuel prices in the UK have risen from $1.82 a litre in June 2021 to $2.19 in May 2022, while in the US prices have soared from $0.81 a litre to $1.17 during the same period, according to data compiled by the Trading Economics website.

With prices rising, Al-Ashmawy said a better alternative to a price cap would be for G7 governments to consider using their tax apparatus to reduce prices at the petrol pumps.

“The only possible way to reduce energy prices for end users is through each government applying variable tax cuts on energy commodities to cool down domestic end user prices up to a certain point,” he said.

“Trying to do so any other way presents formidable complexities that would be difficult to untangle.”

Earlier this month, APICORP reported that the Middle East is boosting investment in oil and gas, bucking the trend seen globally.

The MENA region is forecast to invest $879 billion in energy projects from 2022 to 2026, an increase of 9 percent over the previous five years, according to APICORP’s latest MENA Energy Investment Outlook report.

The report found that global investment in oil and gas stood at $504 billion in 2019, before the pandemic. The figure tumbled to $352 billion in 2020 and is projected to reach $494 billion this year.

In the MENA region, however, investment in oil and gas projects has surpassed pre-pandemic levels and is forecast to rise again this year. In 2019, the region invested $78 billion in oil and gas, representing 15 percent of global investment.

This fell to $72 billion in 2020, but recovered to $86 billion, 21 percent of global funding, in 2021. In 2022, investment is expected to increase again to $90 billion.

“This shows that the MENA contribution to global energy investments in the oil and gas is actually defying the global trend,” Al-Ashmawy said.

“The region is bearing the burden of maintaining energy security, contrary to the narrative that is now prevailing in the media that OPEC+ is not doing enough to ease the energy crisis. That is not true.”

Latest articles

FILE PHOTO: United Arab Emirates Minister of State for Foreign Trade Thani Al Zeyoudi gestures during an interview with Reuters in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, June 30, 2022. REUTERS/Abdel Hadi Ramahi/File Photo

UAE and Kenya complete Cepa negotiations

The UAE and Kenya have completed negotiations on a comprehensive economic partnership agreement (Cepa) between the two countries. It is the 12th Cepa deal secured by the UAE and its third in Africa, after agreements were signed last year with Mauritius and the Republic of the Congo (Congo-Brazzaville). “The UAE-Kenya Cepa will not only boost […]

The 450 companies operating at Dubai Science Park include AstraZeneca, and the free zone plans to add 200,000 sq ft of lab and office space

Dubai Science Park reveals expansion plans

Dubai’s biotechnology free zone is adding 60 percent more offices, laboratories and warehouses over the next few years to cater for an influx of new companies, its senior vice-president told AGBI.  Dubai Science Park, part of Dubai-listed Tecom Group, is planning an expansion of 200,000 sq ft of additional storage and logistics facilities at the […]

A worker at a phosphate production plant in Metlaoui, Tunisia. Phosphate accounts for 15% of Tunisia's exports

Saudi Arabia loans $55m for Tunisian rail renewal

Saudi Arabia has signed a $55 million loan deal with Tunisia to finance the renewal of the North African country’s rail network.  The railway is used to transport phosphate, a sector that makes up around 4 percent of Tunisia’s GDP and 15 percent of the country’s exports. Tunisia plans to produce eight million tonnes by […]

Visitors enjoy the Karnak Temples; the government hopes to entice 30 million tourists to Egypt a year by 2030 tourism egypt

Egypt tourism up 5% in early 2024 despite Gaza conflict

The number of tourists visiting Egypt increased by five percent year on year in the first 40 days of 2024, according to Egypt’s tourism minister, Ahmed Issa. The announcement came after reports in January that visitor numbers for the whole of 2023 reached a record high of 14.9 million, just shy of the 15 million […]