Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

Qatar’s QIA challenges UBS Credit Suisse takeover

man, sheikh Reuters/Imad Creidi
The QIA, run by chairman Sheikh Bandar bin Mohammed bin Saud al-Thani, is consulting with lawyers on whether to make a claim against the Swiss authorities
  • QIA owned 6.87% of Credit Suisse as of December 31 last year
  • Saudi National Bank and Olayan Group also owned stakes
  • About 1,000 bondholders have sued Swiss authorities

The Qatar Investment Authority (QIA) is said to be considering taking legal action against the Swiss financial authorities following the forced takeover of Credit Suisse by domestic rival UBS.

The Qatari fund increased its stake in Credit Suisse in late 2022 as part of the ailing lender’s ultimately failed attempts to bolster its finances following a string of disastrous managerial decisions.

The QIA is the world’s 10th-largest sovereign wealth fund with $475 billion of assets under management, according to the Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute.

The fund owned 6.87 percent of Credit Suisse as of December 31, a January filing to the US regulator shows. Previously, it held 5.03 percent, according to the bank’s website, having first invested in 2008 during the global financial crisis.

Saudi National Bank (SNB) also participated in Credit Suisse’s late 2022 capital-raising, paying 1.4 billion Swiss francs ($1.55 billion) for a 9.88 percent stake in December. Saudi Arabia’s Olayan Group also owns 4.93 percent.

However, in March, Swiss regulators instructed UBS to merge with domestic rival Credit Suisse. Credit Suisse shareholders would receive one UBS share for every 22.48 shares they held in the failing bank.

The deal valued Credit Suisse at 3 billion francs. That would make SNB’s stake worth 296 million francs and the QIA’s 206 million francs, resulting in significant losses on their equity investments.

The QIA is now consulting with lawyers on whether to make a claim against the Swiss authorities. It could go through international arbitration, Reuters reported, citing unidentified sources.

During crisis situations in the banking sector, governments and the legislative authorities can “either decide to suspend certain laws such as, for example, antitrust or competition laws for a period of time to make special rulings or even to announce changes to particular laws”, Michelle Brennan, S&P Global Ratings managing director for financial services methodologies, told a March 21 webinar.

The Credit Suisse collapse comes amid a series of changes at the QIA. This week, Qatar’s ruler issued a royal decree authorising the reorganisation of the fund.

As well as being a major shareholder in domestic corporations such as Qatar National Bank and telecom operator Ooredoo, it has a vast portfolio of foreign assets including stocks, bonds and real estate.

The QIA, via its wholly owned investment firm Qatar Holding, bought a 5.99 percent stake in Barclays in 2008 that helped save the British bank from requesting a state bailout.

The complicated deal, for which Qatar secured handsome fees, led to some Barclays officials to be tried and subsequently acquitted on fraud charges.

QIA Credit SuisseReuters/Pierre Albouy
The QIA, SNB and Saudi Arabia’s Olayan Group collectively owned 21.68% of Credit Suisse
Bondholder problem

In a controversial move, the regulator also announced in March that as part of the UBS takeover Credit Suisse’s additional tier-one (AT1) capital bonds, which had a notional value of 16 billion francs ($17.8 billion), would be written off to zero.

AT1 bonds are considered part of a bank’s capital and can be or written down or converted into equity should it run into difficulties. As such, the bonds offer high yields to reflect their risky nature.

The regulator’s decision to wipe out Credit Suisse’s AT1 bondholders while giving its shareholders 3 billion francs in UBS shares contravenes the usual hierarchy of claims when a business collapses.

Around 1,000 bond investors, representing about one-third of the AT1 bonds, have sued the Swiss regulator, Reuters reported.

Credit Suisse’s AT1 bond documentation clearly gives the regulator “a degree of discretion” to determine whether a so-called viability event has occurred, said S&P Global’s Brennan.

Such an event leads to the automatic, permanent writedown of the AT1 bonds to zero, she said.

“That differs from the documentation for many other AT1 instruments, where writedowns could be temporary with the potential for a write-back in the future,” Brennan added.

“Or a writedown could be to the extent required and where the concept of at least a partial writedown is available.”

Latest articles

Saudi arabia water

$4bn set aside for Saudi water projects

Saudi Arabia will spend $4 billion by the end of the decade on recycling over 2 billion cubic metres of water, about 70 percent of the country’s renewable water sources, an official said this week.  Speaking at the World Water Forum in Indonesia, Mohammed bin Zaid Abuhid, head of the General Authority for Irrigation, outlined […]

Cigarette sellers in Aswan, Egypt. US company Philip Morris says it wants to give smokers in Egypt 'better options than cigarettes'

US cigarette giant buys slice of Egyptian rival

The American tobacco giant Philip Morris International (PMI) has acquired a minority stake in Egypt’s largest cigarette manufacturer. PMI, which owns brands such as Marlboro, L&M, Merit and Parliament and is the world’s top tobacco company by market value, has bought 14.7 percent of Egypt’s Eastern Company, which also includes cigars and pipe tobacco in […]

Visitors admire the House of the Blackheads in Riga, which Eagle Properties hope will be 'the new centre of Europe'

Abu Dhabi developer spots opportunity in Latvia

Abu Dhabi developer Eagle Hills Properties announced a €3 billion ($3.25 billion) investment in the Latvian capital city of Riga, as the UAE continues its investment drive into Europe. Eagle Hills’ Riga Waterfront, which was unveiled on Thursday, will ultimately encompass 8,000 luxury homes for 30,000 residents on a redeveloped site along 5 kilometres at […]

Passengers at Muscat International Airport. Oman plans for it to be joined by six more locations

Oman plans 6 new airports in tourism push

The majority of Oman’s six new airports are expected to be operational by 2028 and 2029, as part of the government’s initiative to promote tourism, a senior government official has said. Work is under way on designing the new projects, which will increase the number of airports to 13, Naif Al Abri, chairman of the Civil […]