Skip to content Skip to Search
Skip navigation

Japanese fund fails to deliver for Gulf investors

Masayoshi Son, CEO of SoftBank, made huge profits from Yahoo but critics say his investment history is mixed Sho Tamura/Aflo via Reuters Connect
Masayoshi Son, CEO of SoftBank, made huge profits from Yahoo but critics say his investment history is mixed
  • SoftBank Vision Fund’s falters
  • PIF and Mubadala invested $60bn
  • Fund worth less than investment

Eight years ago next week Saudi Arabia became a founding investor in SoftBank’s Vision Fund, pledging $45 billion, and Abu Dhabi soon committed another $15 billion.

The creator of the private equity fund, the world’s largest, was Japanese tech guru Masayoshi Son, who, at the time, predicted it would “accelerate the information revolution”.

In October 2016 Japan’s SoftBank announced the launch of the fund along with the involvement of Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund (PIF).

Yet, nearly a decade later, Gulf investors have little to show for their outlays.

SoftBank predicted the fund could eventually expand to $100 billion, which would be approximately the same amount as all US Venture Capital firms had raised in the previous two-and-a-half years, a University of Pennsylvania report states.

PIF and Mubadala receive a 7 percent dividend on invested capital plus a percentage of any returns, the report explains.

The duo did not respond to requests for comment.

Contrary to its name, SoftBank is not a bank but a telecom and information technology investor. Son – widely known as Masa – launched the company in 1981.

SoftBank is also a Vision Fund investor and both entities often co-invest in the same companies, which has led to questions about conflict of interest.

Overall, SoftBank’s Vision Fund has generated a negative return for investors since its inception in 2016, says Atul Goyal, managing director of equity research at Jefferies & Co in Singapore.

Typically, investors in such a fund would expect a 20 percent compound annual return, so $100 invested at inception would be worth about $440 after eight years. Yet the Vision Fund is worth less than what investors committed.

“You can’t catch up for that lost period,” says Goyal. “Is there a potential for some returns in future? Of course, but the probability isn’t high given the fund’s investment track record. It invested when company valuations were steep and rising and stopped investing when valuations corrected dramatically.”

PIF did not put new money into SoftBank’s Vision Fund 2, instead only reinvesting profits from the first iteration, according to media reports.

When asked if the PIF and Mubadala were likely to be content with their vision fund investment, Goyal says: “If they were happy, they would've invested more. They were asked multiple times but haven't invested again.”

Accessories, Bag, Handbag SoftBank owns 20 percent of ridesharing company Didi and has made a paper loss of $8.1 billionZhong Yang/Oriental Images via Reuters Connect
SoftBank owns 20 percent of ridesharing company Didi and has made a loss of $8.1 billion

SoftBank’s results groups the vision funds together. These made an investment loss of $1.2 billion in the 2023 financial year to March 31, 2024. That compares with investment losses of $36.9 billion and $25.1 billion in the preceding two financial years, AGBI calculates based on SoftBank’s earnings.

As of June 30 Vision Fund 1 had made 64 investments and Vision Fund 2 had made 271 investments. Some holdings in publicly listed businesses are now worth far less than their peak value.

Chinese rideshare company Didi’s market capitalisation was $20 billion as of June 30, down from a peak of $79.1 billion. SoftBank owns 20 percent of Didi and has made a paper loss of $8.1 billion on the company.

It has also made a $1.2 billion paper loss on AutoStore and its stake in South Asian “superapp” Grab is worth $300 million less than the fund paid. Conversely, it has an unrealised gain of $5.6 billion on Korean courier Coupang.

“SoftBank has some of the most strategic tech plays in the private markets and has been a key foundation for the AI revolution,” says Daniel Ives, managing director of New York’s Wedbush Securities. “We believe this AI revolution will create many opportunities on the private and public tech front with SoftBank a key player.”

Yet Goyal is unconvinced by that argument.

“SoftBank has talked up the funds’ investments in AI, but that’s not reflected in its portfolio,” says Goyal.

SoftBank and the Vision Fund were the biggest shareholders in office leasing company WeWork. PIF and Mubadala prevented SoftBank’s Son from increasing the fund’s stake in WeWork after his efforts to float the company at a valuation of about $50 billion floundered, explains Goyal.

“PIF and Mubadala have sway on the major decisions but don’t get involved with day-to-day investments,” says Goyal.

WeWork’s bankruptcy plan values it at about $750 million, Reuters reported. SoftBank and the Vision Fund invested $13 billion in WeWork and lent it $5 billion, the university report states.

That PIF and Mubadala bet so big on Masa seems surprising considering his mixed investment record.

He made huge profits from Yahoo Japan but “in 2000, he had about 300 investments and 299 went to zero,” says Goyal.

“The one that didn’t was Alibaba, which salvaged him,” he says.

“In the last 10-20 years very few of his investments have succeeded as Alibaba or Yahoo did.

“Having the vision of what will work is one thing, but then implementing that in terms of value creation by picking up the right management teams, understanding the right business models boils down to stock picking.

“While Masa’s vision about industries and where technology is going has been better than others, his ability in terms of stock picking hasn't been.”

Latest articles

UAE Turkey trade DMCC

More Turkish companies open in UAE after trade deal

A free trade agreement between the UAE and Turkey has been followed by a jump in the number of Turkish companies opening offices in the UAE.  The signing of the comprehensive economic partnership agreement (Cepa) between the two nations in March 2023 was designed to create greater collaboration and remove tariffs on a range of […]

Based on the offer price range, Lulu is set to list with a market capitalisation of between AED20.04bn and AED21.07bn

High demand leads Lulu to upsize IPO stake to 30%

Lulu Retail Holdings has increased the size of its initial public offering (IPO) by 5 percent to 30 percent to potentially raise AED6.32 billion ($1.72 billion) on the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange (ADX) following high demand from investors. The retail chain operator in the Middle East initially offered a 25 percent stake sale. The total […]

Eni had paused its operations at the Zohr gas field but plans to resume drilling in Egypt by the end of the year

Italy’s Eni will restart gas drilling in Egypt and Libya

Italian energy company Eni is reviving its exploration operations on Zohr, Egypt’s largest natural gas field, by the end of the year, its CEO confirmed on Monday. “After some time, we were not really working on Zohr, we will restart drilling by the end of the year, and we are going to drill another well […]

UAE energy minister Suhail Al Mazrouei said the UAE is a model for an ambitious and practical transition to clean energy

UAE to invest $54bn to meet sustainable energy goals

The UAE plans to invest up to AED200 billion ($54.4 billion) to meet sustainable energy demand over the next six years, minister of energy and infrastructure Suhail Al Mazrouei has said. The move intends to “decarbonise economy and achieve net-zero emissions by 2050”, the UAE state-run Wam news agency reported. “Our efforts to diversify the […]